Following the death of Mr. Dashwood, his second wife and three daughters—Elinor, Marianne, and Margaret—find themselves stripped of their family estate by greedy relatives and forced into modest lodgings at Barton Cottage in Devonshire. Elinor, nineteen, possesses a cool judgment and an affectionate heart capable of governing its strongest impulses. In contrast, Marianne is all warmth and romance, prone to extremes of joy and sorrow, mirroring her mother's lack of worldly prudence.
Shortly after settling in their new home, Marianne is rescued from a sprained ankle by the handsome and dashing John Willoughby, sparking an intense mutual attachment that quickly looks like an unspoken engagement. Meanwhile, Elinor harbors quiet feelings for the shy, intelligent Edward Ferrars, brother to their unpleasant sister-in-law, though his dependence on his imperious mother casts doubt upon his future and his intentions. The arrival of neighbors brings new acquaintances, including the quiet, melancholy Colonel Brandon, who falls silently in love with Marianne.
When Willoughby abruptly departs for London without explanation, Marianne follows in deep distress, only to suffer public rejection and a cruel, dismissive letter when they finally meet again. Her unchecked grief precipitates a severe physical collapse, nearly costing her life from a violent fever. Throughout these trials, Elinor maintains her composure, hiding her own heartbreak over Edward's hidden engagement to Lucy Steele. As Marianne slowly recovers, she begins to see the necessity of self-command, while the resolution of long-kept secrets reshapes the futures of both sisters.