The narrative opens with Fenella Barrington completely under the spell of Geoffrey Doyne, an idealistic yet weak-willed poet whose charm masks a deep moral cowardice. Bound to another woman by societal pressure, Geoffrey struggles between his duty and his true love for Fenella. When family pressures and threats of a breach of promise suit force him into a loveless marriage with Jessie Robertson, he leaves Fenella behind, broken and pregnant. The second volume traces Fenella's journey through deep despair and isolation.
Her mother, Mrs. Barrington, driven by ambition and financial desperation, hides the birth of Fenella's child, convincing her the baby died at birth. Later, Fenella marries the wealthy and noble Sir Gilbert Conroy, finding a quiet, respectful affection in her new life but remaining haunted by the past. Years pass, bringing reconciliation with her long-lost child through her faithful nurse, Bennett. The volume explores themes of motherhood, societal expectations, and the lingering agony of a first love that refuses to be forgotten.