Introduction
You likely have an idea for a product that could change your life, but you do not know how to bring it to market. Turning a creative spark into a profitable business feels overwhelming when you face high manufacturing costs, legal hurdles, and ruthless competitors. You risk losing your hard-earned savings if you make the wrong move at the start.
Turning a creative idea into a profitable product requires a clear assessment of market demand, robust legal protection, disciplined prototyping, and relentless execution.
Lori Greiner provides a complete roadmap to navigate this journey from concept to cash in Invent, It, Sell It, Bank It! You learn how to evaluate your idea, protect your intellectual property, build working prototypes, pitch major retailers, and sell through television networks.
- Do you have what it takes to be a successful inventor?
- How do you know if your product will actually sell?
- What steps protect your idea from copycats?
- How do you pitch buyers and pitch on television successfully?
1. Character Traits of Successful Inventors
Only one percent of patents filed every year actually get made and reach the market. Ideas without follow-through go nowhere, and dreams unsupported by stamina fail. You need specific psychological strengths to survive this difficult path.
Successful inventors must possess specific psychological strengths and maintain strict frugality to navigate the difficult path from concept to commercial success.
Core Traits
Psychological profiles of prolific inventors show they share six core tendencies. You must cultivate these traits before you spend money on manufacturing.
- Passion
- Confidence
- Drive and Determination
- Organizational Skills
- Self-Sufficiency and Independence
- Charisma and Showmanship
True passion acts as an irresistible sales tool that inspires support from others. You must be entirely committed to your creation rather than just focused on getting rich. Lori Greiner treats each of her products like her own babies. A QVC colleague joked she could sell mud because her belief is so strong.
Overcoming Doubt
Fear of the unknown stalls people, but you can overcome hesitation by evaluating risks. Active preparation makes challenges manageable.
- Think about what is the worst thing that can happen.
- Determine if you can deal with that worst outcome and move forward.
- Have a backup plan but remain flexible.
Lori Greiner confronted her first patent attorney when he chauvinistically directed all answers to her husband Dan. She replaced him with a female attorney named Natalie. That relationship lasted for 17 years and yielded 120 patents.
You should maintain low overhead and remain frugal even as your business begins to grow. Spending money on fancy office suites is unnecessary when you can work from home. Lori Greiner spent 5000 dollars on her first patent filing and stayed in business for 4 years before indulging in her first big celebratory purchase. She bought a stainless steel Cartier watch in Harrods with her London supplier Sally after a successful QVC Today's Special Value event. One million dollars worth of goods returned means you have accomplished nothing.
2. Evaluating Product Viability
Instincts do not come out of thin air. They rely on subconsciously running through critical questions about market demand, uniqueness, and problem-solving.
Before bringing a product to market, you must rigorously evaluate its commercial viability using structured questions and branding principles.
You can use nine questions to see if you have a winning idea:
- 1. What Is My Product?
- 2. Does It Solve a Problem?
- 3. Is It Unique?
- 4. Is It Something People Will Need or Want?
- 5. Is It Demonstrable?
- 6. How Do I Make It?
- 7. Who Is Your Target Market?
- 8. Is It Safe?
- 9. Is It a Consumable?
Checking off eight or more indicators provides strong preliminary evidence that a product has true commercial potential and mass market appeal. Lori Greiner calls this the hero or zero assessment. Competing with established products is much harder than introducing a brand-new, surprising item. Inventors often suffer from denial when discovering others have created identical designs.
At an Oprah and QVC search event in Los Angeles, Lori Greiner encountered seven different inventors who had independently designed the exact same baby bag.
Uniqueness and Branding
Whittling down a concept to its selling essentials helps in finding a clear name that leaves no doubt about what the product does or why someone would want it. You should follow concrete rules for naming and protecting your concept:
- Whittle down your concept to its selling essentials
- Choose a name that is catchy, descriptive, brief, and easy to say
- Get the name trademarked through the USPTO
Inventors Marc Newburger and Jeffrey Simon considered over eight hundred names for their car seat gap wedge before Simon's mother suggested Drop Stop.
3. Building and Refining Prototypes
A well-designed prototype transforms an abstract idea into a tangible product that generates strong interest while keeping development costs under control.
In the movie The Hudsucker Proxy, Norville Barnes tries to pitch a simple drawing of a hula hoop on paper, leading to total confusion until the physical toy gets into the hands of children who start twirling it. A working prototype allows you to test materials, manufacturing complexity, and customer assembly while fixing design flaws when it is still cheap.
Mock-ups and CAD
Before spending money on expensive prototypes, you should build rough mock-ups using household items or commission computer-aided designs. Mock-ups help test if a design actually works using everyday materials like cardboard, clay, foam, or wood. If you cannot draw accurately, you can hire a design engineer to create a 3-D blueprint called a CAD, or use CAD/CAM technology.
Rick Hopper used paper clips and magnets for his magnetized glasses holder, and the creators of Drop Stop experimented with stuffing and stitching before finalizing their design. You should always ensure that prototype makers, manufacturers, and other industry professionals sign a nondisclosure agreement before sharing your designs. A legally binding nondisclosure agreement protects your intellectual property from being shared or used by others, which is critical if you have not yet filed for a patent.
- Confirm that your prototype maker will sign a nondisclosure agreement that forbids them to discuss, share, or use your idea or design before handing over your specifications.
- Walk away if they refuse.
Inventors should do as much as possible themselves to save money and gain expertise, but they must know when to hire experts for specialized tasks. Doing the work yourself builds the foundational knowledge needed to succeed later. However, when dealing with specialized mass-market rules, safety regulations, and legal compliance, relying on professionals becomes mandatory. Greiner wanted to build her earring organizer herself using her husband's grandfather's woodshop, but she realized wood was wrong and she needed professional plastic materials.
- Do everything yourself, except when you absolutely can't.
- Know when to ask for help or let the experts do their job.
- Stay close to the process and learn as much as possible by shadowing hired experts.
Tooling and Manufacturing Costs
A pre-production prototype is identical to the finished product and is necessary for market research and pitching, though costs can vary significantly. Pre-production prototypes use a one-off mold rather than a permanent mold to keep initial costs lower. While prices vary by size, shape, and material, spending money on a high-quality model makes it easier for buyers to fall in love with the product. Greiner paid $10,000 to create her pre-production prototype for the earring organizer.
Transitioning from a prototype to mass production requires understanding manufacturing processes like plastic injection molding and accounting for steep tooling costs. Mass production often requires specialized factories like injection molders that inject liquefied plastic into molds. The tooling costs for creating production molds can be substantial and usually require external financing like bank loans. Greiner discovered it would cost $120,000 just to make the three molds necessary to manufacture her earring organizer in the United States.
Inventors should handle multiple preparatory tasks simultaneously while waiting for their prototype to be manufactured. Many crucial business steps cost only time and no money, allowing you to build momentum and be fully prepared when customer orders start coming in.
- Contact retailers.
- Look for manufacturing options.
- Investigate funding options.
- Set your price.
- File for your patent and trademark.
Following a structured checklist ensures that you methodically transition from a raw idea to a verified prototype ready for market research. Greiner summarizes the essential actionable steps an inventor must take to properly prepare their design, select correct materials, compare professional bids, and secure confidentiality agreements.
- Finalize the dimensions of your product.
- Research the materials you will need to create it and talk to industry professionals to get recommendations.
- Contact at least two designers so you can compare bids for a CAD design.
- Get the names and locations of at least two prototype makers so you can compare bids.
- Confirm that your prototype maker will sign a nondisclosure agreement.
- Learn from the advice these professionals give you along the way.
4. Conducting Market Research and Pricing
Accurate market feedback and strategic pricing based on magic price points ensure that your product meets real consumer demand without sacrificing volume.
Never manufacture a product or place an order with a factory before receiving actual customer orders. Ordering inventory too soon forces you to pay for units without guaranteed revenue, incurs storage burdens, and wastes the prototype which should instead be used to conduct market research.
Feedback Methodology
Accurate market feedback requires complete anonymity, neutrally phrased questions, and surveying a large cross-section of people. You must avoid friends and family who will either sugarcoat their opinions or be overly critical out of jealousy. Questionnaires should be brief one-pagers with 8 to 10 short, neutral questions, and testing must reach a broad demographic rather than just a guessed target group.
Lori Greiner tested her earring organizer by setting up a small table in front of the Fourth Presbyterian Church on Michigan Avenue in Chicago, and later at various malls and the Taste of Chicago food festival. 75 percent of the people approached on Michigan Avenue agreed to talk and answer questions. 20 percent of women spoke with did not own a lot of jewelry in Lori Greiner's research.
- Do you like this product?
- If you don’t like it, why?
- Would you buy it?
- Do you have a need for it?
- Where would you expect to find this?
- Would you buy this for someone else? If yes, who?
- Would you buy multiples? If yes, why?
- What would you pay for it?
Pricing Strategy
Pricing a product requires balancing manufacturing and distribution costs, competitor pricing, and your gut instinct. Total product cost is calculated by adding materials, labor, overhead, and transportation, then adding a desired profit margin to determine the wholesale cost. Retailers then apply their own markups or keystoning to set the final consumer price.
Lori Greiner shared an example where a $6 total product cost plus a $4 profit margin equals a $10 wholesale cost, which becomes a $19.99 retail price at a 50 percent store margin. 14 percent U.S. mobile market share held by Apple's iPhone is another benchmark to consider.
- Materials + labor + overhead + transportation = total product cost.
- Total product cost + desired profit margin = wholesale cost.
- Wholesale cost to store + freight in / (1 - store margin) = retail price.
Utilize psychological magic price points to make items significantly more appealing to consumers. Pricing items just below whole numbers, such as $9.99, $14.99, or $19.99, makes it psychologically easier for a customer to purchase compared to crossing over into the next dollar bracket. $9.99, $14.99, $19.99, $24.99, and $29.99 magic price points work best.
Avoid over-pricing products for high margins; instead, price affordably to drive higher volume and long-term success. Demanding steep markup percentages can cause a product to fail in the market. Taking slimmer margins on lower-priced items increases overall volume, generates word-of-mouth sales, and keeps products on retail shelves longer.
Eleven-year-old Lukas Pakter started a glow stick business by buying 200 wristbands for $40 and 100 necklaces for $20, selling them at reasonable prices ($1 for wristbands, $2 for necklaces) at a 4th of July festival, and splitting a $300 profit with his stepbrother. $40 spent on 200 glow wristbands and $20 spent on 100 glow necklaces yielded a $300 total profit split between the young founders.
- Write a questionnaire complete with 8–10 open-ended questions that will elicit honest feedback.
- Identify a minimum of three locations for face-to-face consumer research.
- Identify online sites for research.
- Establish that people like your product.
- Establish that there is a demand for your product.
- Establish that people will buy your product.
- Have a good idea of what the market will bear.
- Set a suggested retail price.
5. Business Planning and Financing
A comprehensive business plan combined with disciplined budgeting and strategic funding sources provides the financial operational roadmap needed to launch your enterprise.
While an elevator pitch excites strangers, a full business plan is a multi-page document detailing manufacturing, sales strategy, competition, and financial projections. It must be updated frequently to monitor milestones and ensure the business stays on track, preventing naive assumptions about growth costs.
Budgeting and Valuation
Unforeseen costs frequently arise during manufacturing and product launch, such as design revisions, international shipping fees for samples, compliance failures, and reworking inventory in storage facilities. To absorb these shocks, inventors should add an extra percentage to their contingency fund.
Lori Greiner notes that changes to prototypes can double sample costs, shipping samples between the US and Asia can cost three or four hundred dollars per package, and fixing flawed packaged goods in storage is known as reworking.
- Establish your budget with all contingencies
- Add another 5 to 10 percent to the budget
- Call it the Stuff Happens account
On shows like Shark Tank, investors evaluate what an entrepreneur believes their company is worth based on the ask-to-equity ratio. While venture capitalists often apply multiples based on future projected income, start-ups generally require proven sales history before strict multiples apply.
An entrepreneur asking for $50,000 for 10 percent of the company values the business at $500,000, calculated as $50,000 divided by 0.10.
Raising Capital
Loans from loved ones must include a stated interest rate to satisfy IRS requirements for amounts over a specific threshold, preventing the loan from being taxed as a gift. However, formal repayment dates should be avoided, and lenders must be willing to treat the funds as money they can afford to lose.
When Jeff Bezos solicited investments from friends and family for Amazon, he openly warned them that there was a 70 percent chance they would lose all their money.
- Set up an agreed-upon financial amount and interest rate for loans over $10,000
- Draft a contract stating repayment occurs only when the business produces net income and has over three months of cash
- Insist that lenders only provide funds if they can afford to absorb a total loss
6. Securing Intellectual Property
Patents and trademarks serve as crucial protective shields against copycats and provide necessary legal leverage in the marketplace.
Without a patent, you have virtually no recourse against copycats who steal your product. A patent allows you to send cease-and-desist letters, notify retailers about patent litigation, and assert legal rights. The Drop Stop creators spent five years trying to get their patent; once they secured it and appeared on Shark Tank, they were able to eliminate almost all copycats and dramatically increase sales.
Patents and Due Diligence
Thorough research prevents you from accidentally infringing on existing patents or discovering too late that an identical product already exists on the market. Lori Greiner consulted for Oprah's Next Big Thing event in Los Angeles and met seven different women who were all unknowingly pitching the exact same diaper bag.
- Conduct due diligence to make sure there is no other product on the market like yours and to see if you could be infringing on someone else's patent.
- In order of importance, search online sites including USPTO database, Amazon, Google, online retailers, Facebook, Pinterest, general department stores, specialty retailers, Twitter, big box stores, Bing, Instagram, and Flickr.
Filing for a patent can be financially manageable through various fee categories and structural options. Initial legal fees range from $2,500 to $15,000 depending on the field and attorney seniority. Statutory discounts for small entities with fewer than 500 employees and micro-entities significantly lower official fees. The basic filing fee for a utility patent is $1,600, while a micro-entity receives a 75 percent fee reduction to $400. You might spend as little as $65 for filing a provisional patent, but 75 percent of inventors who file pro se fail to obtain patents against a backlog of 600,000 patent applications at the USPTO.
- Hire a patent attorney.
- Choose your patent.
- Write your claims.
- Review your office action.
- Decide whether to pursue your claims or abandon the application.
Trademarks and Unpatented Products
Trademarks protect brands, logos, designs, and slogans as unique source identifiers within specific product or service categories. You can establish trademarks locally through common law use or nationally through federal registration with the USPTO, granting you monopoly power over the brand name. A single class trademark application costs approximately $1,000.
- Conduct due diligence on the USPTO website to ensure a trademark is available.
- Retain a trademark attorney to conduct a full availability search and assess launch risks.
- Prepare and file an application for registration of the trademark.
Since many products are unpatentable, speed to market, aggressive pitching, retail expansion, and high-profile partnerships are vital to succeed without patent protection. You must blitz the market before copycats arrive.
- Hire a distributor or a firm with extensive retail connections to represent you.
- Get backing from a prominent investor to burnish your image.
- Appear on Shark Tank and make a deal with a shark investor.
7. Pitching Buyers and Retail Chains
A successful retail pitch requires absolute preparation, concise communication of selling features, and relentless outreach to major chains.
You must present your product with precision and enthusiasm. Buyers are busy and lack time for long explanations.
- Make your first sentence as short as possible while highlighting your invention's top three selling features.
- Avoid long-winded explanations, rambling, or going off on tangents.
- Be authoritative, clear, and excited, while staying aware of your audience's body language.
- Switch to your product demonstration or wrap up with a Q&A if you notice you are losing the buyer.
Lori Greiner pitched a 100-piece cosmetic organizer by immediately stating its exact capacity and space-saving metrics.
Anatomy of a Pitch
You must know your numbers and handle operational details without hesitation. Past mistakes should not be hidden.
- Admit mistakes and business failures honestly if asked by a buyer.
- Present past challenges in a positive light to show you are wiser and stronger.
- Explain how you overcame obstacles and plan to prevent the situation from repeating.
- Prepare answers for every question a buyer could throw at you, plus two more.
- Tell the truth if you do not know an answer by saying you will check on it and get back to them.
- Review the standard buyer questions regarding cost, manufacturing location, production time, existing sales channels, color choices, size, weight, patents, competition, packaging, drop-shipping, carton quantities, legal compliance, and third-party testing.
Shelton struggled with alcoholism and took a two-year break after a previous partnership dissolved; she hid this during her Shark Tank pitch and failed to secure a deal. Aaron Krause secured a 15 million dollar retail sales milestone for Scrub Daddy within less than a year after proving his professionalism.
- Acknowledge the administrative work and paperwork a buyer undertakes for a new SKU.
- Assure buyers that you will carefully read guidelines and take care of your responsibilities.
- Consider hiring a representative firm or distributor if you want to bypass setting up individual retail systems directly.
- Dress up for your pitches to show care and respect for the people meeting with you.
- Listen to buyers' concerns and questions without acting combative, arrogant, or hardheaded.
- Take responsibility as a problem solver and project positive energy.
- Examine your prototype to ensure it is in its absolute final, perfect incarnation.
- Build portable props, such as miniature doorways, bathtubs, or kitchen floors, to execute flawless product demonstrations.
Outreach Strategies
You must target the largest players first and use direct outreach methods.
- Consult comprehensive directory resources like The Chain Store Guide or www.chainstoreguide.com to compile buyer contact lists.
- Go big by targeting the largest retailers with the most stores first.
- Cast as wide a net as possible by knocking on every door, calling every phone number, and writing to every email address.
- Use a speed redial system to persistently call busy buyers until they pick up.
- Deliver a one-sentence opening stating you have a revolutionary new product they have never seen.
- Provide a mini-pitch highlighting specific capacity and space-saving dimensions.
- Promise to set your watch and leave in exactly five minutes if they wish.
- Edit, edit, and edit your emails again to make them short and concise.
- Use bullet points instead of long run-on paragraphs.
- Embed an image or provide a link to a YouTube video demonstrating the product instantly.
Lori Greiner used The Department Store Guide, which cost about a 1000 dollars, and traveled 19 cities in 21 days to meet with buyers.
8. Manufacturing and Television Sales
Balancing manufacturing location choices with high-powered television shopping networks creates massive sales momentum and immediate consumer reach.
Manufacturing locally allows for close personal supervision and supports local employment, but costs can be significantly higher, making it difficult to hit consumer price points and remain profitable. Overseas manufacturing reduces costs but increases risk due to a lack of direct oversight, requiring independent third-party audits. Lori Greiner made all her plastic products in Chicago for years, but when she decided to make a wooden jewelry box called the Gold and Silver Safekeeper, she found it cost-prohibitive to produce in the United States, facing a $45 cost to make the jewelry box in China versus $200-$250 to make it in the United States.
- Compile a list of manufacturers with good reputations for producing goods in your product category.
- If producing locally, make appointments to visit and meet with the individuals who would be in charge of your product.
- If producing overseas, contact testing labs to see if the factory you're interested in is in good standing and is socially responsible.
- Look for a representative who can source your product and negotiate on your behalf.
Quality Control and Packaging
Entrepreneurs must establish a strict tolerance for defects and inspect random samples before final payment is released to the manufacturer. Manufacturers typically require a 20 to 30 percent down payment upon signing, with the rest due upon shipping.
Setting a tolerance level at plus or minus 1 percent allows a small wiggle room for minor issues like tiny dirt spots while flagging systemic failures like a faulty zipper found in nine out of fifteen samples. Package design is a science that taps into human emotions and telegraphs key selling points at a single glance. Consumers do not read extensive blocks of text on retail packaging, making clean designs, gorgeous visuals, and clear value propositions essential.
- Come up with a clear vision for how you want your packaging to look (but remain open to suggestions).
- Research and hire a graphic designer and photographer to create your packaging's design.
- Work with a packaging company to make sure your package will secure your goods and pass an eleven-point drop test, if needed.
Television Home Shopping
Television shopping networks, especially QVC, offer unmatched reach and instantaneous sales power for inventors of demonstrable products. Unlike static retail shelves where packaging must do the talking, TV shopping allows products to be actively demonstrated, solving customer problems visually and driving massive sales within minutes. FiberFix sold 16,000 units in ten minutes on QVC, generating $300,000 at retail, matching the $8.5 billion global retail size achieved by QVC in 2012.
10 Key Ideas
- Successful inventors must possess specific psychological strengths, such as passion, confidence, and determination, while maintaining strict frugality to navigate the difficult path from concept to commercial success.
- Before bringing a product to market, you must rigorously evaluate its commercial viability using structured questions and branding principles like the hero-or-zero assessment.
- A well-designed prototype transforms an abstract idea into a tangible product that generates strong interest while keeping development costs under control through careful use of mock-ups and CAD designs.
- Accurate market feedback and strategic pricing based on magic price points ensure that your product meets real consumer demand without sacrificing volume.
- A comprehensive business plan combined with disciplined budgeting and strategic funding sources provides the financial operational roadmap needed to launch your enterprise.
- Patents and trademarks serve as crucial protective shields against copycats and provide necessary legal leverage in the marketplace.
- A successful retail pitch requires absolute preparation, concise communication of selling features, and relentless outreach to major chains using directory resources and direct persistence.
- Balancing manufacturing location choices between local oversight and overseas cost-efficiency requires strict quality control and meticulous packaging design.
- Television shopping networks, especially QVC, offer unmatched reach and instantaneous sales power for inventors of demonstrable products.
- Speed to market, aggressive pitching, retail expansion, and high-profile partnerships are vital to succeed without patent protection or when facing copycats.