When a wealthy American heiress is found murdered and robbed beneath the seat of a train compartment, the case immediately attracts Scotland Yard and the famous detective Hercule Poirot. The victim, Flossie Carrington, was traveling to a house party with a fortune in jewels when her itinerary abruptly changed at an intermediate station. Her grieving father offers a blank check to bring the killer to justice, suspecting his estranged, debt-ridden son-in-law. Inspector Japp focuses on material evidence, chasing footprints, discarded weapons, and a notorious jewel thief who is soon caught pawning the stolen emeralds.
Meanwhile, Poirot rejects the obvious suspects, noting that the mechanics of the crime point to a much deeper deception orchestrated from within the victim's own household. By analyzing the psychological profiles of those closest to the victim rather than just physical traces, Poirot dismantles the false trail left by the murderer. The narrative culminates in a swift revelation in the victim's own home, where the true identity of the conspirators comes to light through careful reasoning and an understanding of human nature.